• Home
  • About
  • News
    • Civil Rights
    • COVID-19
    • Criminal Justice & Policing
    • Education
    • Healthcare
    • Investigates
    • Politics
    • Working & the Economy
  • Commentary
  • Subscribe
  • Briefs
  • Contact
  • Donate
Search
  • Home
  • About
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Briefs
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Donate
Tennessee Lookout

THE STATES NEWSROOM

  • Criminal Justice & Policing
  • Education
  • Healthcare
  • Politics
  • Working & the Economy
  • Investigates
Protesters in front of the Senate side of the U.S. Capitol urge Congress to pass the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program in December 2017. (Mark Wilson/Getty Images)
Protesters in front of the Senate side of the U.S. Capitol urge Congress to pass the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program in December 2017. (Mark Wilson/Getty Images)
  • Civil Rights
  • Politics

U.S. House passes Dreamers bill over GOP objections, as immigration debate intensifies

By
Daniel Newhauser
-
March 19, 2021
Facebook
Twitter
Linkedin
Email
Print

    WASHINGTON — The U.S. House took up two bills Thursday that would grant legal status to broad groups of immigrants living and working in the United States, including a pathway to citizenship for hundreds of thousands of undocumented people brought to the country as children.

    The measures mark the first step towards what advocates for immigration reform hope will be a year or two of substantive action on the issue. However, as debate on the House floor on Thursday made clear, the caustic rhetoric surrounding a recent upsurge of young migrants crossing the Southern border shows that chances for bipartisanship are dwindling.

    Overall, nine Republicans supported the measure giving a path to citizenship to immigrants protected under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, compared to seven who voted in favor of the measure in 2019. It passed 228-197.

    However, rather than reflecting new broad support in the congressional GOP for this policy, the uptick is likely attributable to more Republicans holding swing district seats after sweeping the November elections.

    For instance, Florida Reps. María Elvira Salazar and Carlos Gimenez, who beat Democrats Donna Shalala and Debbie Mucarsel-Powell, respectively, were new lawmakers to vote for the Dreamer bill. So was Rep. David Valadao, a Californian in his fourth term.

      We are telling Dreamers all over our country, 'We see you. We hear you. And we know your home is here in the United States of America.   – U.S. Rep. Greg Stanton, D-Arizona

    Other moderate Republicans supporting the measures included Reps. Mario Diaz-Balart of Florida, Brian Fitzpatrick of Pennsylvania, Mark Amodei of Nevada and Fred Upton of Michigan.

    After casting her vote, Salazar told reporters that she though the bill was little more than a partisan gimmick, but wanted to show Democrats a gesture of good faith, because she has a competing bill in the works that would pair a pathway to citizenship with more border security.

    “I want to send the right message to the Democrats that I’m willing to work with them,” she said. “Let’s see if now they’re going to work with us, so they will not say that the Republicans are the racists, or the Republicans are the uncompassionate ones.”

    Democrats said the legislation is a moral imperative. House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer, a Maryland Democrat, said during debate on the bills that immigrants with temporary status and others living in the shadows, including Dreamers and farmworkers, deserve relief.

    “Immigrants are a reason why America became the world’s most powerful and most prosperous country,” he said. “This legislation today is a major achievement and will hasten the moment when 3 to 4 million immigrants and their families can breathe a little easier, a little freer, knowing that they are welcomed and valued here in America, that they are truly a part of our country.”

    House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer (D-MD) wears a protective mask while walking through the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 12, 2021, ahead of the House of Representatives vote on Rep. Jamie Raskin's (D-MD) resolution calling on Vice President Mike Pence to invoke the 25th Amendment, removing President Donald Trump from office. On Wednesday, House Democrats plan on voting on articles of impeachment. (Photo by Stefani Reynolds/Getty Images)
    WASHINGTON, DC – JANUARY 12: House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer (D-MD) wears a protective mask while walking through the U.S. Capitol on January 12, 2021 in Washington, DC. Today the House of Representatives plans to vote on Rep. Jamie Raskin’s (D-MD) resolution calling on Vice President Mike Pence to invoke the 25th Amendment, removing President Trump from office. On Wednesday, House Democrats plan on voting on articles of impeachment. (Photo by Stefani Reynolds/Getty Images)

    Others centered the issue as a matter of local importance. For instance, U.S. Rep. Greg Stanton, a Democrat, said he voted “Yes” for the roughly 24,000 Dreamers in his home state of Arizona, many of whom work as essential employees, doing everything from stocking grocery shelves to practicing medicine.

    “We are telling Dreamers all over our country, ‘We see you. We hear you. And we know your home is here in the United States of America,’” he said. “Dreamers are essential to rebuilding our economy and it’s long past time we put them on a path to citizenship.”

    However, predicting a tougher road for the legislation in the U.S. Senate, Republicans by and large opposed both measures, citing the familiar objections to “amnesty” for people who came here without prior authorization, especially in the wake of an unfolding overwhelming situation of increased migration at the Southern border.

    “On the heels of this border crisis that is going on right now, there’s a bill on the House floor to create amnesty, to create a bigger magnet, saying, ‘Come to the Southern border,’” House Minority Whip Steve Scalise, (R-La.), said on the House floor.

    Other hard-right Republicans objected to specific items in the bills. For instance, Rep. Jim Jordan, an Ohio Republican who was managing floor debate on the Dreamer bill, objected to a section that would create a grant program to fund nonprofit organizations who help immigrants through the application process.

    “This bill gives amnesty to 3 million illegals and uses American tax dollars to help those same illegals apply for the amnesty,” Jordan said. “The disrespect that the Democrats have for the American taxpayer, it’s astounding to me.”

    House members later Thursday night on a 247-174 vote passed a bill to give legal status to undocumented agricultural workers. Thirty Republicans backed that legislation.

    One Republican member who voted for a similar bill in 2019, Rep. Mike Simpson of Idaho, laced into members of his own party on the House floor for tying the issue to the current migrant situation.

    “This bill is not about what is happening on the border, but that seems to be what all the debate is about,” he said. “This bill is not amnesty, it does not grant anybody amnesty. It allows individuals to get right with the law and to become legal workforce in the United States. It’s about providing a stable legal workforce for the people who put food on our tables.”

    A senior White House official told reporters Thursday they are indeed seeing an increase in unaccompanied children coming across the border — 29,000 so far this fiscal year, in fact — but said the administration is trying to clean up the mess left by the Trump administration, and would be happy to work with Republicans on doing so.

    The Biden administration released statements earlier in the day supporting House passage of both bills, but also noting they want Congress to take up broader immigration reform, like the U.S. Citizenship Act. That bill, based on Biden’s policy outline, would pair these measures with broader efforts to give legal status to millions more immigrants, as well as some border security measures and aid to Latin American countries to address what the White House sees as root causes of northbound migration.

    U.S. Sen. Bob Menendez, (D-N.J.), a New Jersey Democrat who is carrying that bill in the U.S. Senate, told reporters Thursday that he appreciates the House is moving the conversation along, but wants to include these pieces of legislation in a larger conversation about broad, bipartisan immigration reform.

    • TAGS
    • DACA
    • Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals
    • Dreamers
    • immigration
    • President Joe Biden
    Share
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Linkedin
    Email
    Print
      Previous articlePermit-less handgun carry rolls through Senate
      Next articleEditor’s Column: Kelsey’s defense of slavery exception fails Four-Way Test
      Daniel Newhauser
      Daniel Newhauser
      Daniel Newhauser is a freelance journalist based in Washington, D.C. His work has appeared in The Atlantic, The Daily Beast, National Journal, Politico, Roll Call, VICE News and several other publications. He can be found on Twitter @dnewhauser.

      RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

      Inside the Tennessee Senate chambers. (Photo: John Partipilo)
      Politics

      Revamped unemployment bill takes Senate step

      A 2018 photo from a TIRRC demonstration. (Photo: Jon Dragonette/TIRRC Facebook)
      Civil Rights

      TIRRC pushes Congress to create easier path to citizenship

      (Photo: Dickersonfors20, Facebook)
      Healthcare

      Comprehensive Pain Specialists, former senator settle fraud allegations for $4.1M

      Latest News

      Inside the Tennessee Senate chambers. (Photo: John Partipilo)

      Revamped unemployment bill takes Senate step

      Politics April 22, 2021
      A 2018 photo from a TIRRC demonstration. (Photo: Jon Dragonette/TIRRC Facebook)

      TIRRC pushes Congress to create easier path to citizenship

      Civil Rights April 21, 2021

      Latest Commentary

      Tennessee State Capitol (Photograph: John Partipilo)

      Commentary: A Modest Proposal for the General Assembly,

      Commentary April 21, 2021
      Knox County Sheriff's office (Photo: KCSD Facebook)

      Commentary: Keep a keen eye on sheriff departments

      Commentary April 19, 2021

      Briefs

      Shelby County adds mental health training for firefighters

      Healthcare Dulce Torres Guzman - April 22, 2021

      Memphis minister joins national group calling for end to filibuster

      Civil Rights Dulce Torres Guzman - April 15, 2021

      Hispanic leaders develop resources to help businesses

      Working & the Economy Dulce Torres Guzman - April 14, 2021

      School shooting at Knoxville high school leaves one dead

      Criminal Justice & Policing Holly McCall - April 12, 2021

      Grassroots groups weigh in on Nashville Budget

      Civil Rights Dulce Torres Guzman - April 12, 2021

      Subscribe

      Follow

      Tennessee LookoutFollow5,53910,918

      Nonpartisan, nonprofit news site dedicated to covering Tennessee government, policy and politics. Send tips to [email protected]

      Tennessee Lookout
      TNLookout avatarTennessee Lookout@TNLookout·
      2h 1385296145245736963

      This is sad news.

      Natalie Allison@natalie_allison

      Former Sen. Thelma Harper died today, her family has confirmed to some members of #tnleg. https://t.co/2yy0Wyvtvk

      Reply on Twitter 1385296145245736963Retweet on Twitter 1385296145245736963Like on Twitter 138529614524573696314Twitter 1385296145245736963
      TNLookout avatarTennessee Lookout@TNLookout·
      3h 1385290956426072068

      On weekly @TNSenateDems press conference, @yarbro addresses a move to cut unemployment eligibility in half although raising the payment slightly: "Anyone who says this is an increase is spinning you."

      Reply on Twitter 1385290956426072068Retweet on Twitter 1385290956426072068Like on Twitter 13852909564260720683Twitter 1385290956426072068
      TNLookout avatarTennessee Lookout@TNLookout·
      6h 1385235718608408579

      ICYMI, former state senator @DickersonforS20 was dropped from a federal lawsuit alleging fraud but, as @StockardSam reports, he's still on the hook for $4.1 million to settle claims.

      Comprehensive Pain Specialists, former senator settle fraud allegations for $4.1M – Tennessee Lookout

      Former state senator Steve Dickerson was dropped from a federal lawsuit alleging fraud by Comprehensive Pain Specialists.

      tennesseelookout.com

      Reply on Twitter 1385235718608408579Retweet on Twitter 13852357186084085792Like on Twitter 13852357186084085795Twitter 1385235718608408579
      Load More...
      X

      Republishing Guidelines ►

      ▪ You must give Tennessee Lookout credit, including https://tennesseelookout.com and author.

      ▪ If you publish online, include the links from the story, and a link to Tennessee Lookout.

      ▪ Stories may be edited for in-house style or to shorten. More substantial changes should be noted as additional and conducted by your publication.

      ▪ You can publish our graphics and any photos that are credit to Tennessee Lookout with the stories with which they originally appeared. For any other uses, you must seek permission from us at [email protected]

      ▪ If you share the story on social media, please mention TNLookout on Twitter and tennesseelookout on Facebook.

      ▪ Don't sell the story.

      ▪ Don’t sell ads against the story. Feel free, however, to publish it on a page with ads you’ve already sold.

      U.S. House passes Dreamers bill over GOP objections, as immigration debate intensifies

      by Daniel Newhauser, Tennessee Lookout
      March 19, 2021

      1

      Creative Commons License

      Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site.

      ABOUT US
      Now more than ever, tough and fair journalism is important. The Tennessee Lookout is your watchdog, telling the stories of politics and policy that affect the people of the Volunteer State.
      Contact us: [email protected]
      FOLLOW US
      © Tennessee Lookout 2021
      Adjust Font Size
      MORE STORIES
      Rutherford County Courthouse. (Photo: Rutherford County Facebook)

      Fired Rutherford Circuit Court Clerk employees file suit claiming harassment

      Civil Rights March 8, 2021
      A Tennessee state trooper chases a protester holding a sign on 5th Avenue, N. in Nashville, across from the Cordell Hull Office Building. (Photo: Ray Di Pietro)

      Commentary: The spirit of Bull Conner is alive and well in...

      Commentary August 18, 2020
      Edit with Live CSS
      Save
      Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete.