Commentary

Statewide Power Poll: Majority strongly oppose recent special session COVID bills

Half of respondents agree that legislation is “deplorable” and “extremely short-sighted”

November 19, 2021 10:05 am
Gov. Bill Lee with Republican legislative leadership after a recent press conference. (Photo: John Partipilo)

Gov. Bill Lee with Republican legislative leadership after a recent press conference. (Photo: John Partipilo)

The Tennessee General Assembly’s recent special session on COVID-19, which dramatically lowered the state’s COVID-19 response on everything from masks to vaccines, was met with big blowback in a statewide Power Poll.

More than two-thirds of the voting Power Poll members in Knoxville, Memphis, Chattanooga, and Nashville, as well as the state’s rural and suburban counties, say they “strongly oppose” the package of bills that was passed. About half agreed with a description that the legislation is “deplorable, extremely short-sighted regarding public health, and not at all in the best interest of the state.”

In other Power Poll findings, members voiced a range of opinions on the main cause of the Democratic Party’s recent state-level losses and President Biden’s plummeting approval ratings. Of those choosing a specific key reason, most blamed the party’s progressive Democrats “who have pushed Biden too far left and refuse to compromise.” Half of respondents, however, cited a combination of factors.

Finally, in our “Semi-Important-But-Not-Really-Significant Question of the Month,” members are evenly divided on what to do, if anything, about Daylight Saving Time. Slightly more than one-third of members think we should adopt Daylight Saving Time year-round, while an equal number wants to stick with what we’ve got because “it’s really just not that big of a deal.” 

Here are the specific questions and answers of the November Statewide Power Poll:

Gov. Bill Lee just signed into law a hardline package of legislation approved by the Tennessee General Assembly to reduce “federal government overreach” and curtail the ability of local governments to enact COVID-related mandates. It also limited private businesses’ ability to require employees to be vaccinated, among other workplace measures. Regarding the legislation, do you:

  • Strongly support it: 11%
  • Somewhat support it: 10%
  • Somewhat oppose it: 9%
  • Strongly oppose it: 68%
  • Neither support nor oppose it: 1%
  • Not sure: 1%

Which of the following comes closest to describing your view on the legislation:

  • I think it is right on the money: 5%
  • I don’t agree with everything in it, but I do think this is the normalcy we need to be moving toward: 15%
  • Legislators were simply representing the majority views of their constituents; that’s what they are elected to do: 5%
  • I am not surprised at all, but I’m still amazed at how far they went to push their right-wing agenda: 23%
  • I find their actions deplorable, extremely short-sighted regarding public health, and not at all in the best interest of the state: 48%
  • None of the above: 5%

The Democratic Party is reeling nationally in the wake of the loss of the Virginia governor’s race by a large margin, a squeaker in New Jersey, and President Biden’s plummeting approval ratings. Which of the following would you say is MAINLY responsible?

  • President Biden, who has not articulated his agenda effectively to the American people: 4%
  • Moderate Democrats, who are blocking the progressive wing’s platform: 2%
  • Progressive Democrats, who have pushed Biden too far left and refuse to compromise: 28%
  • The GOP’s artful messaging on Critical Race Theory in classrooms, the cost of Biden’s spending proposals, the economy, and other issues: 11%
  • A combination of all or most of these: 50%
  • None of the above: 6%

THE POWER POLL’S SEMI-IMPORTANT-BUT-NOT-REALLY-SIGNIFICANT QUESTION OF THE MONTH: The Daylight Saving Time/Standard Time debate resurfaced once again with the twice-a-year resetting of our clocks earlier this month. No one, it seems, is happy. Proposals being kicked around to address the dissatisfaction include staying on Daylight Saving Time year-round (i.e., keep the time we were on from March to November), remaining on Standard Time year-round (with its earlier sunrises and sunsets), or even redrawing the time zones. What are your thoughts?

  • The U.S. should adopt Daylight Saving Time year-round: 37%
  • The U.S. should just stay on Standard Time year-round: 19%
  • Middle Tennessee should move to the Eastern Time Zone, but West Tennessee should remain on Central Time: 3%
  • Keep the status quo. It’s really just not that big of a deal: 37%
  • We should adopt Australian Time so it will always be tomorrow: 5%

DISCLAIMER: The Power Poll is not a scientific poll. Its nonpartisan survey questions are directed only to the most powerful and/or influential people in Tennessee’s major metro areas (and in other U.S. cities). It affords a fascinating glimpse into the thoughts, opinions, and beliefs of those who can make change happen. This Power Poll was sent to 2,894 people in Memphis, Chattanooga, Knoxville, Nashville, and others living in the state’s rural and suburban counties. 731 responded, for a response rate of 25%.

CONTEXT, PART I

A sweeping set of COVID measures was recently passed by the 132 members of the General Assembly who met in a wild and furious special session. At the root of the rollback in existing COVID treatment standards were calls for individual liberty and the rights of people not to wear masks or be vaccinated. Republican, conservative lawmakers advocated that government has no role in mandating individual health decisions. They won big time.

They went after mask mandates.

The mask and vaccination measures were so conservative that they made Republican Gov. Bill Lee, who previously had some good things to say about masking, chart a more right-leaning course. Broadly speaking, mask mandates by governmental entities will now be almost impossible to implement. Public schools will not be able to require masks unless a school jumps through numerous hoops. Public universities cannot require masks (or vaccines) unless funds from the federal government are in jeopardy of being withheld. As to mask mandates in the private sector, businesses will be able to determine their own policies.

The legislature also went after vaccine mandates.

Private businesses can require that their employees be vaccinated. However, it is forbidden for an employer to require any worker to show the he or she has been vaccinated, and this applies to both the public and private sectors. Minors going forward cannot get a vaccine without parental consent. And it is now harder to sue for COVID-19 damages.

The state—and the Republican Party—flexed its muscle in a myriad of other ways.

Only the governor can now issue executive orders to county health departments, including the counties that have their own health departments, such as those in Memphis, Knoxville, Nashville, and Chattanooga. Those cities/counties have operated until now with degrees of authority and independence much greater than other county departments. Read it this way: our Republican state government was telling the heavily Democratic urban metro areas that the state is calling the shots.

And seemingly out of left field, for a session supposedly focused on COVID, the General Assembly made partisan elections for local school boards a reality. Other actions were taken to mess with urban Democrats, specifically the offices of district attorneys general, but let’s leave it at that.

The measures that were passed, and the speed with which they were passed, paint a picture of a legislature wholly unfettered by any real Democratic opposition and deeply enmeshed with the Republican right. A forceful group of mainline business concerns was able to push some of the measures that harmed them in a more moderate direction, but generally speaking, conservative Republicans ruled like a party with no fear of political retribution or consequences.

Taken as a whole, what resulted was a triumphal exercise in conservative one-party rule, a gathering up of partisan wish lists that they then easily passed. Even members were astonished at how little attention was being paid to it all. It just glided past.

I would call this a high point for Tennessee conservatism. They won big. The rugged individualism of rural interests absolutely crushed the dweeby, rational empiricism of urban areas. Throughout American history, individual liberty has always run headfirst into the polis, government, and the other fabrics that we stitch together to safeguard and protect our common interests. The special session saw that liberty run wild.

CONTEXT, PART II

Meanwhile, we asked two more questions:

First, we brought up the health and wellness of the Democratic Party, given that it lost the Virginia governor’s race (50.6% R to 48.7% D) and won the New Jersey gubernatorial race in a closer-than-expected contest (51.2% D to 48% R).

(Incidentally, Nashville Power Poll member Matt Wiltshire took issue with us describing the loss in Virginia as being by “a large margin” and the race in New Jersey as being won in a “squeaker.” He was correct; a 3-point margin in New Jersey was indeed close, but not a squeaker, and the characterization of the Virginia margin was just wrong, much to our regret. Good heads-up, and thank you Matt.)

The largest number of Power Poll members feel it’s not just one main problem dogging the Democrats, but a smattering of problems that are working against them. That said, those selecting one main cause of the party’s problems were most critical of the progressive wing of the party—its inflexibility, its shunning of moderates, its pulling of Biden to the left, and so on. Also, Republicans came in for praise for their deft messaging in areas like the economy and Critical Race Theory in the classroom.

Finally, as to our question regarding daylight saving time, the numbers show that people are all over the map. The largest camps advocate doing nothing, or adopting Daylight Saving Time year-round. In close contention is moving to Standard Time year-round. Of one thing we can be certain: it’s really dark, really early.

Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

Bruce Dobie
Bruce Dobie

Bruce Dobie is the founder and CEO of Power Poll. Power Poll surveys influential and powerful people in 20 ciites across the United States. Its results afford a fascinating glimpse into what’s in the minds of those who run our cities, states and nation.

MORE FROM AUTHOR