U.S. Supreme Court’s recent environmental ruling renews spotlight on TVA

By: - July 11, 2022 8:03 am
The Tennessee Valley Authority's Cumberland Fossil Plant. (Photo: Courtesy of TVA)

The Tennessee Valley Authority’s Cumberland Fossil Plant. (Photo: Courtesy of TVA)

The U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling limiting the power of the Environmental Protection Agency to regulate carbon emissions that cause climate change has renewed the spotlight on the Tennessee Valley Authority, the nation’s largest public utility and Tennessee’s primary source of electricity.

The case involved EPA efforts to implement a key provision of the Clean Air Act in a challenge brought by 15 Republican-led states. That provision, which never went into effect, would have required existing power plants to shift from dirty sources of energy — such as coal — to cleaner sources, including solar and wind, as part of an urgent effort to reduce global warming.

TVA has long relied on coal power. But the federal utility is an outlier in the nation’s utility infrastructure, where power companies are typically owned by individuals or investors and subject to the oversight of shareholders and public utility commissions.  TVA is self-regulated —delegated its own authority under the Clean Air Act.

Environmental groups in Tennessee are now eyeing a different federal tool to place limits on TVA’s emissions:  A 2021 Biden Administration executive order requiring a “lead by example” from all federal entities in order to achieve 100% carbon pollution-free electricity in federal agencies by 2030.

Attorney Amanda Garcia with the Southern Environmental Law Center. (Photo: SELC)
Attorney Amanda Garcia with the Southern Environmental Law Center. (Photo: SELC)

“The Court’s ruling puts a premium on the Biden Administration ‘lead by example’ order,” said Amanda Garcia, an environmental attorney and director of the Southern Environmental Law Center. “I think there’s a real opportunity for Biden to work with TVA on clean, affordable, renewable energy.”

TVA officials noted last week they have already made progress in decarbonization efforts, independent of the now-derailed EPA rules. TVA’s goals, set out in a strategic plan last year, are to reduce its 2005 emission levels 70% by 2035 — and net-zero by 2050.

“We believe decarbonization is the future,” a statement from TVA spokesman Scott Fiedler said. “TVA is leading efforts to move the industry and the nation faster and farther, together. It will take a lot of work to research, develop and deploy technologies that, frankly, we don’t have today at a competitive price.”

Environmentalists say TVA is not on track to meet those reduction goals — which go further than the proposed EPA rules struck down by the Supreme Court, but fall short of the aggressive approach  urgently needed to address a warming planet.

“They will need some kind of incentive,” said Bryan Jacob, solar program director for the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy. “Some kind of carrot or stick to get them there.”

TVA in 2021 announced plans to retire its remaining coal-fired plants, among the oldest operating fossil fuel plants in the nation. At its peak, TVA operated 12 coal-fired power plants. More than half of those have since been retired. The utility is in the process of retiring and replacing two more: its Cumberland and Kingston coal plants.

But a looming dispute remains over what will replace those plants. TVA announced plans to replace its Cumberland plant with natural gas —another fossil fuel source instead of solar or wind energy.

“They have unfortunately doubled down,” Garcia said.

TVA is currently studying future plans for the Kingston Fossil Plant, where other dangers posed by coal plants were brought into sharp focus in 2008, when millions of cubic yards of ash — the physical byproduct of burning coal — spilled into neighboring communities and waterways, destroying homes and sickening workers hired to clean it up. Legal challenges brought by those workers and their surviving family members remain ongoing.

While environmental groups in Tennessee continue to pressure TVA to pivot to cleaner energy, they also caution that the impact of hamstringing regulation over fossil fuel power is not confined within state borders.

In June, the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation and the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency issued an advisory about elevated levels of mercury in fish found in three Tennessee reservoirs: the Cheatham County, Center Hill and Dale Hollow reservoirs. The advisories noted that “atmospheric deposition due to the global burning of coal is the most frequent reason for elevated levels of mercury in fish.”

“What happens in Tennessee’s rivers and streams is not likely to come just from TVA, but neighboring states,” Garcia said. “The mercury in our fish is likely coming from the coal plants all around us.”







Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

Anita Wadhwani
Anita Wadhwani

Anita Wadhwani is a senior reporter for the Tennessee Lookout. The Tennessee AP Broadcasters and Media (TAPME) named her Journalist of the Year in 2019 as well as giving her the Malcolm Law Award for Investigative Journalism. Wadhwani is formerly an investigative reporter with The Tennessean who focused on the impact of public policies on the people and places across Tennessee.